Why some design elements age gracefully (and others don’t)

Designers and dealers share what helps interiors mature well over time, and which choices are more likely to date.
Image may contain Home Decor Chair Furniture Couch Rug Plant Architecture Building Indoors Living Room and Room

In her Manhattan apartment, interior designer Ceara Donnelley layers textiles and antique pieces to give the interior a timeless quality, softening plaster walls, exposed beams and a terracotta floor.

Dean Hearne

It is no secret that some interiors age effortlessly, while others feel passé not long after they are completed. But what makes the difference? The answer is rarely a matter of a specific style or look, and more often lies in how a space has been put together, and how time has been allowed to shape it.

‘One of the most important decisions is to build a room gradually rather than buying everything at once,’ says James Thurstan Waterworth. ‘Collecting pieces from different places, periods, and points in your life’ allows interiors to develop ‘depth and character’, with each object contributing to a layered sense of meaning. By contrast, buying everything ‘from the same source, or within the same design moment’ risks creating a space that ‘reflects that particular period and as styles inevitably shift, the room risks feeling dated’.

In the Wiltshire farmhouse of James Thurstan Waterworth and Scarlett Supple a Jacques Adnet lamp and a Carl Auböck brass...

In the Wiltshire farmhouse of James Thurstan Waterworth and Scarlett Supple, a Jacques Adnet lamp and a Carl Auböck brass ashtray rest on an 18th-century French desk, paired with an Eighties ‘Quinta’ chair by Mario Botta. James and Scarlett bought the kimono on their honeymoon in Japan.

Martin Morrell

For James, this has little to do with visual density, and everything to do with personal taste and inclination. ‘A timeless space doesn’t have to be busy or maximalist; it can still be calm or minimal,’ he notes. Designing ‘from instinct rather than from trend forecasting’ leads to rooms that feel more settled over time, because they are not chasing an imagined future aesthetic. He is also vocal about the importance of flexibility. ‘There may be seasons where you crave more colour, pattern, or warmth, and others where you prefer a quieter, more muted palette. Small elements such as textiles, cushions, art, lighting, and decorative antiques can shift easily, allowing the room to evolve without losing its core identity.’

There should also be room for missteps, he argues. ‘The idea of a room remaining “forever perfect” is unrealistic. What matters more is creating a space that can adapt, expand, and continue to feel meaningful as your tastes and lifestyle evolve. Timeless design is not about freezing a room in time, but about allowing it to grow.’

Image may contain Architecture Building Furniture Indoors Living Room Room Couch Plant Chair Art and Painting

In the drawing room of a Belgravia house by Octavia Dickinson, architectural detailing provides a calm framework for decoration, allowing colour, pattern and furnishings to evolve over time without unsettling the room’s balance.

Helen Cathcart

A similar sense of continuity underpins Octavia Dickinson’s approach. She sees traditional detailing as a way of giving interiors clarity and direction from the outset. Cornices and skirtings in rooms, and traditional moulding on joinery provide what she describes as ‘a strong starting point’, making it possible to decorate in many different ways without losing coherence. She often introduces panelling ‘to give it structure and make it feel grounded and traditional’, pointing out that these elements were originally practical rather than decorative. ‘Internal wall panelling originally evolved as a form of insulation before becoming decorative, while dado rails and skirtings have a practical purpose too, protecting walls from furniture and everyday wear. These elements endure because they are functional as well as timeless.’

Wallpaper plays a similar role. Octavia emphasises how they ‘age beautifully’ because ‘they provide a base that can then be embellished in different ways over time.’ Even in smaller details, she favours materials that sit comfortably across periods. ‘I love a brass tap, but I’ve also found myself increasingly drawn to nickel. This warm silver finish is very traditional and ages beautifully in bathrooms. Nickel became popular in the late Victorian era due to its tarnish resistance and soft tone, and I think it can look both very modern and deeply traditional, a perfect finish that rarely feels dated.’

Nicola Harding cleverly used ‘Lancaster wallpaper in rose from Jean Monro as a backdrop for a collection of nautical...

Nicola Harding cleverly used ‘Lancaster’ wallpaper in rose from Jean Monro as a backdrop for a collection of nautical paintings found on an antique sourcing trip, in a bedroom of this country house.

Even within classical interiors, restraint remains essential. Octavia enjoys ‘being creative with paint, playing with combinations of colour on walls, woodwork and ceilings’, but cautions that ‘pushing this too far can quickly date an interior – particularly if it’s used throughout a whole house’. When ‘every skirting, wall and ceiling is a different colour’, she notes, the result can feel ‘contrived and overly fussy’. The same applies to traditional drapery: ‘swags and tails, frills and trims can be wonderful’, but too much can quickly ‘definitely date a room’.

Where Octavia stresses structure as a foundation, Christian Bense approaches depth with a note of caution. For him, architectural detail is a starting point rather than a shortcut. Architectural features can support a scheme, but they cannot carry it on their own. ‘These details can be used to help to create a layered interior, not solve it entirely,’ he says, noting that people often assume that adding more will automatically produce richness. In practice, this approach frequently leads to spaces that feel unsettled rather than resolved. The same logic applies to stylistic mixing, which is often mistaken for complexity. ‘It’s perceived that mixing styles will give a home a more layered look, but in reality this just creates a confusing and messy interior.’

Image may contain Indoors Interior Design Architecture Building Dining Room Dining Table Furniture Room and Table

In the dining room of Christian Bense’s flat, walls painted in ‘Slate II’ by Paint & Paper Library are paired with a ceiling in Farrow & Ball’s ‘London Stone’, with a checkerboard artwork created by Christian above the fireplace.

Mark Anthony Fox

Ultimately, he sees these elements as something that should recede rather than dominate. ‘These architectural details are a background noise, not the headline act,’ he says, cautioning against letting them take precedence over the rest of the room. Depth, in his view, emerges not from accumulation or display, but from hierarchy and an understanding of what should be allowed to speak quietly.

Image may contain Flooring Living Room Indoors Room Furniture Floor Interior Design Rug Hardwood Wood and Couch

In the London flat of the late Robert Kime, a William Morris carpet anchors the study, its rich hues and intricate pattern echoing antique rugs in the adjoining drawing room and bedroom beyond.

Simon Upton

From a dealer’s perspective, Dorian Caffot de Fawes draws a clear distinction between objects that remain convincing over time and those that quickly reveal their moment. Pieces that last, he suggests, are rarely driven by spectacle. Instead, they tend to be conceived with ‘a high understanding of proportion, restraint and quiet elegance rather than fashion and impact’. Materials also play a decisive role. Dorian is sceptical of finishes once celebrated for their modernity. ‘Overly synthetic finishes, high-gloss cellulose lacquers often become yellowish, and lack the patina that one wants from furniture that has matured gracefully,’ he says. Form, too, can age unevenly. ‘Aggressively sculptural or overly literal’ designs tend to feel dated once their novelty fades. What time seems to favour instead are ‘noble and “honest” materials, like good quality wood and timber veneers, stone, bronze, ceramic. These materials don’t compete with the interior,’ he notes, ‘they settle into it, becoming more interesting as they age rather than less.’

Image may contain Home Decor Chair Furniture Lamp Art Painting Couch Plant Indoors Interior Design and Table

In the Menorca living room of antique dealer Dorian Caffot de Fawes and his interior designer husband, Thomas Daviet, the tones of the Victorian floor tiles are echoed by 1970s armchairs in a Romo fabric, a coffee table made by shortening the legs of a dining table, and a Dutch mid-century oak and seagrass chair.

Salva López

William Green comes back to the simplest test of all: whether decoration suits the building it sits within. ‘One way to help a room design feel timeless is to consider the period and architectural style of the house when furnishing,’ he says. ‘You don’t have to be overly strict and match everything to the century or the specific style of the house, but always keep it in mind.’ His examples are pointed. ‘An elegant Regency house may be overpowered by rooms stuffed with heavily carved 17th century oak and walls hung with Flemish tapestries,’ while ‘dainty Regency furniture in a large and early Manor House is going to feel quite weak.’ For William, ‘a room's design and decoration always work best when it compliments the house it's in’. He is equally cautious about altering what cannot easily be undone: ‘Think very carefully when changing the structural interior and the layout knocking down walls and changing the usage of rooms – 90% of the time the house’s original layout is the best.’

Image may contain Home Decor Architecture Building Furniture Indoors Living Room Room Table Couch Art and Painting

In a layered interior by William Green, pieces from different periods sit comfortably together, creating a room that feels balanced and settled rather than fixed to a single moment.

Christopher Horwood